Skip to main content

Critique of the Integrated Environmental Strategies (IES): An Initiative of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from the Perspective of the Green Neoliberalism





In June 1998, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) established the Integrated Environmental Strategies (IES) program in an effort to assist developing countries evaluate public health, economic, and the environmental advantages associated with integrated planning in the process of addressing both the greenhouse gas emissions as well as local environmental concerns (EPA 2010). Presently, the EPA is in partnership with government agencies in implementing the Integrated Environmental Strategies program in eight (8) developing countries throughout the world in an effort to assist these countries address their problems economically, socially, culturally and environmentally. These countries include Argentina, Brazil, Chile, China, India, Mexico, Philippines, and the Republic of Korea. The goal of this paper is to critique the Environmental Protection Agency’s Integrated Environmental Strategies program from the perspective of the Green Neoliberal theoretical framework using Michael Goldman’s book “Imperial Nature” as the basis of analysis in an effort to see some of the assumptions of the development framework that are in view within this development project and how these assumptions affect the process through which the project is been implemented.
The goal of the IES program of the EPA is to provide tools and strategies in the process of analyzing and quantifying environmental, public health issues as well as socio-economic and mutual benefits in developing countries (EPA 2010). The project also provides analytical mythologies in co-benefits analysis as well as provides technical know-how and why in the process of evaluating global issues from local perspectives in the areas of local energy consumption and the formulation of environmental policies and initiatives. It also helps developing countries construct the professionalisms needed in the area of integrated energy and environmental analysis and also promotes and enhances local support systems in the process of implementing measures and policies for mutual benefits.
The IES program is implemented based on systems and processes developed by each individual countries participating in the program coordinated by the EPA. The program is designed to address local needs of each of the developing countries and to create a sustainable system of local capacities building. Policy makers in developing countries along with their partners in the United States identify key objectives that the program seeks to address. This process is carried out by a research team, which assesses the mutual benefits of both the developing country and their U.S. Their analysis is based on the human health advantages associated with the use of clean or renewable energy. However, this process could be protracted to enhance economic development.
Green Neoliberalism originated from early 1990s after the World Bank and the IMF received several criticisms from stakeholders about how their policies and strategies negatively impacted the people to whom their development policies and strategies were directed (Goldman 2005). As a result of these external pressures, the World Bank instituted the Green Neoliberal development framework in an effort to encourage developing countries to lead to a market-driven economy, encourage cuttings in public expenditures for social services, deregulation, privatization of government agencies and to eliminate the conception of public good and community. It is a development discourse, which use the language of markets, efficiency, consumer choice, and transactional thoughts as well as individual autonomy to shift the risk from government and corporations to individuals (Goldman 2005). It also promotes and enhances the economic development of developing countries through the expansion and intensification of their market structures through increase in numbers, frequency, repeatability and the formalization of transactions among actors (Goldman 2005). Neoliberalism as a development framework encourages a state to adopt a market driven approach to economic and social growth, which is based on the ideology of the neoclassical theories of economics development, which emphasizes the role of the private sector in the process of determining the political and economic agenda of the state (World Development Report, 2009). 
The World Bank and other financial institutions through these new initiatives are able to engage with stakeholders in countries of operations in diverse ventures ranging from environmental sustainability to irrigation, etc. However, the creation of Green Neoliberalism by the World Bank and her counterparts led to the global shift in development paradigm in which access to knowledge and expertise created an atmosphere of power relations (Goldman 2005). In this new paradigm shift in the structure and process of development, the ones who have the "knowledge" also have the "power" to control the "other" thus creating a system of perpetual dependency on the former; that is, the developed countries.
Some of the major assumptions associated with the EPA’s IES program implemented in developing countries with reference to the Green Neoliberal development framework are that, stakeholders in developing countries become reliant on their U.S. partners for professional support, it also creates a new market venue for U.S. base corporations for the marketisation of their products and services, the issue of knowledge and power relations, and developing countries are required to restructure their agencies in order to meet the requirements for the EPA’s IES program, which reinforce the dependency syndrome between the North and the South, the East and the West, the West and the Rest, developed and developing countries.  
After careful assessment of the goals and objectives of the EPA's IES programs, I came to the conclusion that the Green Neoliberalism development discourse significantly influenced this project’s formulation and process. This is because the goals and objectives of the IES program create a system of dependency by developing countries on the United States for technical and professional support. This project is an expansion of the United States capitalist system because these countries will be depending on the EPA for materials and equipments that can only be bought from the US based corporations thus expanding the current gap between poor countries and rich countries such as the United States.  

Reference
1. Goldman, Michael (2005). Imperial Nature: The World Bank and Struggles for Social Justice in the Age of Globalization. New Haven: Yale University Press.
2. U.S EPA (2010). “Integrated Environmental Strategies (IES) Program.” Website: http://www.epa.gov/ies/basicinfo.htm Accessed: 11/29/2010.
3. World Bank Group (2009). “World Development Report: Spatial Disparities and Development Policy.” Website: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDR2009/Resources/Outline.pdf. Accessed: 11/29/2010.







Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ethics, Human Conduct and Values: Slavery’s Pleasant Homes

Ethics, Human Conduct and Values:
Slavery’s Pleasant Homes
Slavery’s Pleasant Homes told by L. M. Child is a sorrowful story that presents a clear picture of how racism, slavery, marriage, and classism as institutions were used by Frederic Dalcho to oppress and humiliate George, Rosa, Mars and Marion. The purpose of this paper is to discuss, investigate and analyze all the major elements in the story and how these elements can be linked to the various characters such as Frederic and George Dalcho, Mars, Marion and Rosa. This paper seeks to investigate who is morally culpable for perpetrating the worst thing that humanity has ever encounter. It is also my goal to recommend possible power structures that can be substituted for those  which existed in the story. I also attempt to address current sexist, racist and classist practices that are demonstrated in the United States and how these practices promote and encourage oppression, male supremacy, violence, and the exploitation of the pow…

Regenerative Agriculture through Drip Irrigation Systems, Three-Sisters Garden Model and Small-scale Animal Farming: A Reflection from the Past

Drip Irrigation installed about 30cm away from raised-beds at a height of 1m. Source: RESPECT Ghana
The world is presently experiencing major changes that have been largely linked to anthropogenic activities and these changes influence the climate systems, leads to variations in the Earth's climate systems. “Global Warming” is causing many devastating changes in the earth’s global climate systems which also have significant implications on landforms, biodiversity, water systems, and atmospheric system. There is a need to take drastic actions now, if our species is to survive throughout the next 25 years. In order to continue to survive as a species, there is a need for us to become more proactive both at the local, national, and international levels on how we use our energy sources for a more sustainable future. A future that not only define our species, but also take into careful account our neighbors the plants, animals, water, land, air, and all those microscopic living and non-l…

A Classical Theory Paper on The Movie "Brazil."

Source: URL: http://www.flickeringmyth.com/2013/02/the-terry-gilliam-retrospective-part-3.html

The Criterion Edition of the 1985 movie known as ‘Brazil’ detailed significant classical theoretical concepts of Max Weber. The paper discussed how specific scenes and dialogues in the movie are related to Weber’s view of the world from a theoretical perspective.


Source:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Wh2b1eZFUM Weber (1864-1920) was a pessimistic classical theorist unlike Karl Marx (1818-1883) who was more optimistic about events occurring in society. He believes that society will gradually become difficult and there is nothing that we can do to fix it. His theory was based on two ultimate themes which are reflected in his entire theoretical thesis: firstly, “the emergence of capitalism as the dominant form of organization in the West and secondly, the relationship between ideas and actions” (McQuaid, summer 1 Lecture, 09). These two components of Weber’s theoretical works were reflective…